add callback types for array_uintersect etc v2 #3312
Conversation
array_diff_uassoc array_diff_ukey array_intersect_uassoc array_intersect_ukey array_udiff_assoc array_udiff_uassoc array_uintersect_assoc array_uintersect_uassoc array_uintersect
…iddle variadic param
Fixes regression of issue 9697
| if ( | ||
| (!$phpDocType instanceof NeverType || ($type instanceof MixedType && !$type->isExplicitMixed())) | ||
| && $type->isSuperTypeOf(TemplateTypeHelper::resolveToBounds($phpDocType))->yes() | ||
| ($type->isCallable()->yes() && $phpDocType->isCallable()->yes()) |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Alternatively, I could broaden the type of the callbacks in function map to callable and then I wouldn't need this. I'm not sure what's better.
| || ( | ||
| $className === null | ||
| // These functions have a variadic parameter in the middle. This is not well described by php8-stubs. | ||
| && in_array( | ||
| $functionName, | ||
| [ | ||
| 'array_diff_uassoc', | ||
| 'array_diff_ukey', | ||
| 'array_intersect_uassoc', | ||
| 'array_intersect_ukey', | ||
| 'array_udiff', | ||
| 'array_udiff_assoc', | ||
| 'array_udiff_uassoc', | ||
| 'array_uintersect', | ||
| 'array_uintersect_assoc', | ||
| 'array_uintersect_uassoc', | ||
| ], | ||
| true, | ||
| ) | ||
| ) |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
I didn't want to complicate it with the php8-stubs. The issue is that the stubs look like this:
/** @param array|callable $rest */
function array_intersect_uassoc(array $array, ...$rest): array
{
}which then overrides the newly introduced stub. So I needed to skip them somehow. I suppose an alternative would be to skip php8-stubs where the last parameter is ...$rest, but I prefer this more explicit way.
|
Hi, I appreciate your effort but I'm not really sure about this approach. This isn't really valid PHP: function array_udiff(
array $array,
array ...$arrays,
callable $value_compare_func,
): array {}So stubs shouldn't be written like this and info with this structure should not appear in reflection. The fact you need to handle this situation in src/Rules/FunctionCallParametersCheck.php (in the rules layer) is a sign we might break a bunch of code that would forget to handle it. To modify the signature on the fly based on the actual call args with my suggestion from here #3282 (comment) would be much more palatable for me. |
3 participants
This is a more advanced alternative to #3282
Fixes phpstan/phpstan#7707
I didn't go the route you suggested here: #3282 (comment) . Instead, I bypassed php8-stubs for these functions so that they don't conflict with the new stubs. And I added support for in-the-middle variadic parameter to
FunctionCallParametersCheck. IMO handling it directly in the reflection should cause less inconsistency.